Skip to content
Craft Beer Times | Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington Review

Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington Review

Scarlet Lane Brewing IrvingtonReview
Scarlet Lane Brewing IrvingtonReview
Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington Review
The Quick Version
Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington serves up a delightful mix of comforting ambiance and delicious eats in Indy's Irvington neighborhood, offering a cozy spot reminiscent of a favorite retro video game secret level. With a menu featuring crowd-pleasers like loaded fries, double cheeseburgers, and artisanal charcuterie, plus an array of fine beers, this brewpub knows how to satisfy cravings—despite occasional service bumps like long wait times. It presents an unforgettable atmosphere complete with tasty makeovers of classic dishes and a vibe as inviting as a warm blanket on a cool Midwestern night. So while they might miss a beat now and then, the spirit of Scarlet Lane Brewing is unshakable, making it a worthy destination for anyone seeking good food, great beer, and a genuine local experience.
Visit Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington's Website
Get Directions
Reader Rating43 Votes
4.5



The Buzz about Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington

Hey, fellow hop-heads and grub-lovers! Strap in, because we’re about to dive deep into the flavorful world of Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington. In fact, if you’re tapping your toes in Indy’s historic Irvington neighborhood, a visit to Scarlet Lane is kind of like finding the secret level in your favorite retro video game—it’s a super bonus of yummy delights!

The Scarlet Lane Scoop

Let’s face it, ambiance and good eats are the PB&J of the restaurant universe. So, when you waltz into Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington, expect that familiar, cozy sensation—like your most comfortable pair of slippers coupled with the warm hug of a good brew. It’s the place where, for years, beers and cheers intermingle in a seamless, sudsy symphony.

Fries, Flavors, and the Occasional Wait… Oh My!

Imagine this: you’re feasting on loaded fries that make your tastebuds do the happy dance. So far, so delish, right? But hang tight, because sometimes, even the mightiest of eateries stumble on the service front. A recent trek to Scarlet Lane indeed left some yearning for their grub a tad longer than anticipated. Picture it—45 minutes for fries and a burger becoming a 90-minute saga. Granted, it could be a hiccup, and those fries? Still worth the wait.

Burger Bliss and Charcuterie Charm

Fear not, because Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington also knows how to make a rebound that would impress any sports aficionado. Enter the double cheeseburger—a masterpiece of smash patties seasoned to perfection. And the charcuterie? A delightful homage to Hoosier hospitality that could convert any non-believer.

Cheers to Good Beers and Club Sandwich Nirvana

Let’s raise a glass to Tara and her crew, who’re serving not just beers, but an experience. They turn the noble club sandwich into something that could have sandwich aficionados weeping with joy. It’s “amazing” with a capital “A”, and highly recommended for those who like their hops with a side of extraordinary.

A Bit of Grease Lightning and Bumpy Beats

Picture this: a mac n’ cheese that’s moonlighting as a grease pool. That’s been the unfortunate case for someone’s comfort food dreams. And let’s not forget the soundtrack—while a great tune can amp up the ambiance, when it tips to the loud and abrasive end of the scale, you might feel more in a club than a brewpub.

Mouthwatering Makeovers and Unwavering Vibes

But wait—let’s flip the script! The patty’s got an upgrade, and it’s turning heads (and taste buds) with every succulent bite. Those once-lamented fries? Still scoring taste touchdowns, with buns and toppings on point. And the vibes? They remain unparalleled, as cozy and welcoming as your favorite blanket on a chilly Midwestern eve.

Bottom Line? Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington is like that high school buddy who sometimes forgets your birthday but throws the most epic surprise parties. They’ve set the bar high, and admittedly, sometimes fall short. However, with the tasty food revamps and the unbreakable spirit of the place, there’s always room for another round.

So, let’s wrap this up with a neat little bow: If you’re cruising through Irvington, you owe it to yourself (and your stomach) to drop by Scarlet Lane. Whether for the first or fiftieth time, you’re in for a brew-tastic journey. Enjoy the epic eats, savor those cold ones, and don’t forget to tell them to keep the tunes just a smidgen softer, will ya?

And there you have it, friends—a review that pairs honesty with a side of sizzle. From suds to service, Scarlet Lane Brewing Irvington whips up the kind of memories that stick, like that last slice of pizza you thoughtfully saved…for breakfast. Go on, give them a whirl, and who knows? You just might catch them on one of their shining-star, better-than-your-favorite-band’s-comeback-concert days!

Dustin

Dustin is a writer about craft beer and a professional brewer in the city of Chicago. He has written for several magazines and has over a decade of experience in the beer industry. He is currently working on a book about the history of beer in Chicago.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Final Score