East-End Brewery’s Farewell: Toronto’s Real Estate Crunch

The Forged Path of Muddy York Brewing Co. in Toronto‘s Parkview Hills

Welcome to the charming neighbourhood of Parkview Hills, where the crossroads of Woodbine Avenue and O’Connor Drive are enlivened by a gem known as Muddy York Brewing Co. This modest yet vibrant brewery has embedded itself in the fabric of Toronto’s east end. For years, Muddy York Brewing Co. has been the go-to spot for craft beer enthusiasts, connoisseurs, and the community alike.

A Local Staple with Big Dreams

In the heart of this close-knit enclave, the brewery has not only served up an amazing variety of craft beers, but it has also woven itself into the lives of its patrons. Indeed, it has flourished tremendously, garnering customer reviews that often echo praise for both the brew and the atmosphere. A testament to their success, Susan Michalek and Jeff Manol, the dedicated owners and life partners, aspired to expand their horizons, setting their sights on the burgeoning market of Stouffville, located north of the city.

Unexpected Turns: A Relocation Dilemma

Yet, life has a way of throwing curveballs, and for Muddy York, one came hurtling along when their Toronto landlord decided to sell the building. Michalek, with a mix of disappointment and resolve, elaborated, “We definitely didn’t want to leave. And we definitely wanted to stay and extend our lease there.” Their plans to extend their roots within the community they had grown to love were suddenly in jeopardy. The task of securing an affordable alternative in the same area proved elusive, leaving relocation as the sole recourse.

The bond they’ve formed with Parkview Hills is palpable. “It’s just a shame because we’ve spent many years really working on our current location and doing our best to attract people, and it’s just become a really lovely community hub,” lamented Michalek. The thought of parting ways with their loyal customers and losing the unique vibes of their establishment clearly weighs heavy on their hearts.

The Challenge of Staying Afloat in Toronto’s Real Estate Market

The landlord’s proposal hit hard, but it wasn’t exactly a bolt from the blue. Michalek wasn’t shocked by the sale plan and even disclosed that they were given a chance to purchase the property. Alas, the asking price soared beyond their financial reach. Michalek candidly broke it down: “The building is for sale for far more than we would be willing to pay. For what you’re getting, that space is very overpriced.” According to Realtor.ca, the price tag attached to their quaint locale at 22 Cranfield Road stood at an eye-watering $2,745,000.

The question looms large regarding the future of entrepreneurship in the city: “What has become of Toronto, and how can we keep interesting and vibrant businesses, and small business owners, going if it’s such a hostile environment for them?” Michalek asked, giving voice to the concern felt by many small business owners in Toronto facing similar predicaments.

The Wider Impact: A Tale Told by Many

Not Just A Solitary Story: CFIB Ontario’s Take

The plight of Muddy York Brewing Co. is far from isolated, as relayed by Julie Kwiecinski, Director of Provincial Affairs for Ontario at the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB). “I wouldn’t put this as an isolated incident. I think the problem is bigger than just this one business,” Kwiecinski stated, highlighting the pervasive struggle of many small businesses grappling with the daunting costs plaguing Toronto and other areas.

Kwiecinski shed light on the stark statistics: “52 per cent [of CFIB members] said they were operating at or less than normal revenue levels and 61 per cent said they still carry COVID-19-related debt, averaging over $134,000.” This paints a concerning picture for the small business landscape, with Ontario’s small business confidence levels hitting rock bottom.

Specific Struggles for Ontario’s Craft Breweries

Operating a craft brewery in Ontario presents its unique hurdles. Kwiecinski points to high tax rates on beer and a nine cent per beer can tax as significant obstacles, urging the province to heighten its support for small businesses to prevent such challenging situations.

“The province can be doing things to lower taxes for all businesses so things like this don’t happen and businesses have more money in their pocket,” she advocated, calling for a more supportive framework for entrepreneurs.

Looking Forward with Optimism

Despite the impact of these recent developments, Michalek’s spirits remain unbowed. Together with Manol, they hold onto the excitement for their craft and future endeavors. “We’re still really excited by our brand… we’re going to keep our heads down, work on this new space, and we’ll keep going,” Michalek assured with a hopeful tone. The journey of Muddy York will continue, albeit on a different track than the one they’ve traveled for so many years.

Muddy York will be parting ways with their cherished spot but only in physical terms. Their essence is anchored in their passion and the memories they’ve created with their customers, which will travel with them to their next destination. They will remain in the space until the end of February, with the date of the Stouffville location’s opening remaining an eager expectation.

In essence, while the address may change, the heart and soul of Muddy York Brewing Co. will undoubtedly pour into their new home, wherever it may be, continuing to serve as a beacon for beer buffs and a testament to the indomitable spirit of small businesses in Toronto and beyond.